Let’s talk about death and taxes
90 years ago, Kath’s uncle Joe, who she never met, died, aged 10, of diphtheria. It’s not a disease we hear about much these days. Diphtheria is rare in the UK, because babies and children are routinely vaccinated against it. Diphtheria has some similar symptoms to Covid-19, but is caused by bacteria rather than virus. It is highly contagious, spread by coughs and sneezes, or through close contact with someone who’s infected. You can also get it by sharing items, such as cups, cutlery, clothing or bedding, with an infected person (https://www.nhs.uk/conditions/diphtheria/).
At that time in 1930, without the National Health Service, Joe’s parents had to pay the doctor direct for his care (£14), and it was only in the early 1930s that vaccinations for diphtheria became widely implemented in the UK, but the campaign was still underway in 1943 to get wide enough vaccination to eliminate this disease as a major cause of mortality (BMJ July 10, 1943 page 44).
9 years ago today Kath died, she was 67. She was diagnosed with adenocarcinoma lung cancer in November 2010 after having fluid drained from her lungs in an NHS hospital. From Dec to March 2011 she had an operation and 3 rounds of chemotherapy, all of which made her ill on top of the effects of the cancer. My brother and I spent a lot of time with her at home while she was going through this. It was a lifestyle very much like this confinement now, a different pace, quite disconnected from the outside world.
A few days before this day 9 years ago, Kath was doing OK, so much so that both my brother and I felt we could leave her and go off and do some other things back in our normal lives. But then she picked up a bug, her temperature shot up and things happened very quickly, went from bad to very bad, and we had to call an ambulance in the middle of the night. Sometime in the morning, I have no idea exactly what time, it is all a blur, in a horrid room in A&E, we witnessed the life leave her body.
What I realise now, from all the coverage of the coronavirus, is that Mum was an example of a person “with a pre-existing condition” who dies because of a virus. She was going to die anyway, but it could have taken another few months. It could have been a gradual decline with time to say her goodbyes, with some peace and dignity. I tell you, this was not a peaceful death. It was a terrible experience for her and us, it would be for anyone, that feeling of suffocation while conscious, knowing it was coming and nothing could be done. How frightening. Traumatic. Each time I hear about the deaths of people from coronavirus mostly having pre-existing conditions, I think of this and what that means.
Something I have been shocked to read is how many people die of flu in a “normal” year. I assume that the bulk of those are also people “with pre-existing conditions”. I am shocked that we do not do more to prevent the spread of the diseases that have this effect. I have read up about this term “herd immunity” that has been bandied about. I have had the flu jab the last two years, and my husband has had it a lot of years as he has asthma. I have only ever thought of immunisation as a protection for self, not in the context of creating a herd immunity, to protect others. Why is it not used more widely, more strategically, to prevent flu and other diseases spreading to vulnerable people?
At the moment we are focussing on Covid-19 as a killer. But these other viruses and bacterial infections, that are relatively mild for fit healthy people, are killers for others. Each time a person battles in to work with a sneezy nose and/or a cough, dosed up with something that masks the symptoms, just to get through the day, getting to work on a crowded tube or bus or train, squashed in a lift, hands on a stair rail – that person is a link in a chain spreading disease that ends up somewhere with deaths. And probably not a peaceful death. How much pressure does that put on the NHS, on Care Homes? Why is the social and work pressure to keep on working no matter what, rather than to self isolate and prevent the spread of disease to others?
I am thinking about the 28,000+ deaths so far in the UK. We are all trying to ignore this enormity as just numbers, because it is too hard to cope with. There is a focus on getting “back to normal” and carrying on. But there has been a great tragedy, and this requires grieving and learning.
It has taken a long time for me to get over what I witnessed 9 years ago today. I think it will take a long time to get over this experience we are having now.
There are big questions about how money is distributed. As a nation the majority of people are complying with the government recommendation of staying at home and adapting their businesses, with great hardship and losses to many. Up and down the land people are raising money, making scrubs, and protective visors to support the NHS. It is wonderful to see how much people care and how many people volunteer to do what they can to help their fellow human beings.
There is the fundamental distinction between the right and left politics, whether you believe that services supporting the health and wellbeing of people in need should be funded by charity or by taxes. The National Health Service is not a charity, it is funded by taxes, and long may we have it and cherish it and give it the share of funding it requires. And not just the health service, but the social care services, delivered through local government, which have been squeezed and under funded for so many years.
I really hope that people will remember this when we next get a chance to vote for who is in charge of deciding how the tax money is spent.
